top of page
  • Writer's pictureThinking Orange

One Mock to Rule Them All: Pooling Results from Draft Super-Predictors

Researchers use meta-analysis to synthesize the results of many studies on a single topic. It's a particularly useful tool when any one study likely contains error, or when studies produce conflicting results. Looking at a bunch of datasets in the aggregate can reduce the uncertainty associated with individual studies and get you closer to the truth.

That is the basic theory behind this mock draft. I selected five "super-predictors" from the Huddle Report's rankings of the ten most accurate mock draft creators over the past five years. Selections were made purely based on mock draft availability (darn you, paywalls!). I also picked a sixth super-predictor from the Huddle Report's list that scored extremely well but only did mocks for the past three years. This group of six experts formed my pool of super-predictors.

To make projections I simply identified the player most of the super-predictors chose in each spot, starting at the top of the draft and moving sequentially through the pick order. Where there was no clear consensus, I considered agreement about position (a few corner cases required a bit more thought, which I lay out below). The picks do not represent my own player evaluations or opinions about what a team should do. Just what a team is likely to do.

Round 1 Mock Draft


1. Cincinnati Bengals: Joe Burrow—QB, LSU

Anything else would be a shock.


2. Washington Redskins: Chase Young—EDGE, Ohio State

The experts unanimously agree on this one as well. Longtime stalwart Ryan Kerrigan is on the final year of his deal, so Young replaces him as the Redskins continue to build a quietly talented defense.


3. Detroit Lions: Jeff Okudah—CB, Ohio State

Four out of six experts have the Lions selecting Okudah. With Slay's recent departure in free agency it makes sense for Detroit to look for secondary help. This is a potential trade up spot if the Chargers want to leapfrog the Dolphins for a QB.


4. New York Giants: Isaiah Simmons—DEFENDER, Clemson

Simmons transcends any single position. He epitomizes the modern defender and makes for a forward-thinking pick from a backwards-thinking GM. Three of six experts agree on this pick.


5. Miami Dolphins: Justin Herbert—QB, Oregon

Five of six experts agree that the Dolphins will select a QB with the fifth pick. But, they disagree about who it will be. Herbert edges out Tua Tagovailoa three to two.


6. Los Angeles Chargers: Tua Tagovailoa—QB, Alabama

Five of six experts also agree that the Chargers will select a QB. With Herbert gone, the most likely selection is Tagovailoa.


7. Carolina Panthers: Derrick Brown—DT, Auburn

All six experts predict that the Panthers go defense. Brown is the next most likely pick with Okudah and Simmons off the board.


8. Arizona Cardinals: Jedrick Wills Jr.—OT, Alabama

Four of six experts agree not only that Arizona will pick an offensive tackle, but also that it will be Jedrick Wills Jr. There is such a large top tier of tackles that it's somewhat surprising so many experts are on the same page. Have the Cardinals tipped their hand, or created an effective smokescreen?


9. Jacksonville Jaguars: Javon Kinlaw—DT, South Carolina

Sacksonville lives! Three of six experts had the Jaguars selecting a DT, so with Brown off the board Kinlaw is the clear pick.


10. Cleveland Browns: Mekhi Becton—OT, Louisville

All six experts had the Browns selecting an offensive tackle in this spot, but there was no consensus on who that would be. Two experts have them going with Becton's "massive upside", and two had them opting for Georgia's Andrew Thomas. It seems like the Browns are keying in on combine performance and measureables (two experts had them taking Ezra Cleveland and Tristan Wirfs). Becton is the most enticing from that perspective.


11. New York Jets: Tristan Wirfs—OT, Iowa

The experts agree on this one—the Jets opt to protect their young signal caller by giving him the greatest leaper at offensive tackle in recorded history.


12. Las Vegas Raiders: CeeDee Lamb—WR, Oklahoma

All six experts expect the Raiders to take a WR with their first pick. Three say they select Lamb, two say Henry Ruggs, and one says Jerry Jeudy. Lamb winding up in Las Vegas would be unfortunate for the Broncos, as he would be an excellent fit in Pat Shurmur's offense.


13. San Francisco 49ers: Jerry Jeudy—WR, Alabama

A majority of the experts think the Niners will take a wide receiver. With Lamb off the board, Jeudy is the pick, just edging out Henry Ruggs III. Flipping a defensive tackle on an expiring deal for a top wide receiver prospect in their trade with the Colts is a coup, and for my money Jeudy is the best WR in this class.


14. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Andrew Thomas—OT, Georgia

It looks like tackle Andrew Thomas is the likely pick for the Bucs. Gotta protect their new, elderly star (looking at you, Tom).


15. Denver Broncos: Henry Ruggs III—WR, Alabama

Five out of six experts have the Broncos selecting a WR, though only one projects Ruggs to be the pick. Because Lamb and Jeudy are off the board, however, the Alabama speedster is the likely choice (though he may be a trap).


16. Atlanta Falcons: CJ Henderson—CB, Florida

The Falcons appear to have honed in on edge rusher K'Lavon Chaisson and cornerback CJ Henderson. Four of six experts think Henderson is the pick though, so he replaces Desmond Trufant in Atlanta.


17. Dallas Cowboys: K'Lavon Chaisson—EDGE, LSU

CJ Henderson also appears to be a likely pick up here if available. If not, it looks like undersized rusher K'Lavon Chaisson will be the selection.


18. Miami Dolphins: Xavier McKinney—S, Alabama

The experts project the Dolphins will use their second pick to take the first safety off the board. Pairing McKinney with free agency addition Byron Jones and mainstay Xavien Howard would give the Dolphins a formidable secondary.


19. Las Vegas Raiders: Trevon Diggs—CB, Alabama

A CB is the Raiders most likely second selection. Jon Gruden and Mike Mayock can consider Diggs, A.J. Terrell, Jaylon Johnson, and C.J. Henderson, if available. The experts suggest Diggs is the probable pick.


20. Jacksonville Jaguars: Jordan Love—QB, Utah St.

This pick seems to be somewhat up in the air. But two experts project the Jaguars to take QB Jordan Love, putting a damper on Mustache Mania in Jacksonville.


21. Philadelphia Eagles: Justin Jefferson—WR, LSU

The experts unanimously project a wide receiver to the Eagles at pick 21. Most even agree that the wideout will be LSU's Justin Jefferson. Jalen Reagor and Tee Higgins are options as well.


22. Minnesota Vikings: Denzel Mims—WR, Baylor

The Vikings find Stefon Diggs' replacement in draft season riser Denzel Mims. The experts think that CB is also a possible option for Minnesota here.


23. New England Patriots: A.J. Epenesa—EDGE, Iowa

Defensive end is a popular pick for the Patriots. They could go with Zack Baun, but most experts have New England selecting Epenesa.


24. New Orleans Saints: Patrick Queen—LB, LSU

If Jordan Love is still on the board the experts think the Saints will be interested, but otherwise it looks like Queen will be the pick. The Saints have spent years watching Deion Jones and may decide they want their own version.


25. Minnesota Vikings: Josh Jones—OT, Houston

This is the first pick where the experts are truly at odds. Two have the Vikings taking a CB, two have them taking a WR, and two have them taking an OT. Because they selected a WR with their first pick, they likely will not take one again in this spot. With no consensus among the experts it's truly a toss-up—let's project them to double down on Mims by taking a tackle.


26. Miami Dolphins: Yetur Gross-Matos—EDGE, Penn State

The Dolphins are projected to bolster their defense, this time adding talent up front. Offensive line is also a strong possibility here.


27. Seattle Seahawks: Grant Delpit—S, LSU

The experts agree that the Seahawks are likely to go defense with their first round pick, but disagree on both position and player. Safety and edge look like strong options, but with Gross-Matos off the board Delpit is the pick.


28. Baltimore Ravens: Kenneth Murray—LB, Oklahoma

Four of six experts have the Ravens selecting a LB, and three believe it will be Murray. Things get harder to project towards the end of the round, so this is a surprisingly clear pick from the experts.


29: Tennessee Titans: Ross Blacklock—DT, TCU

The experts have defensive end Yetur Gross-Matos as the most likely pick for the Titans in this spot. But because he's not available, we'll go with a different defensive line player that the Titans will hope can replace Jurrell Casey.


30. Green Bay Packers: Brandon Aiyuk—WR, Arizona State

The experts unanimously predict that the Pack will take a wide receiver—the question is who it will be. Denzel Mims is a popular choice but he was selected by the Vikings, so Green Bay goes with a different speedster.


31. San Francisco 49ers: Jeff Gladney—CB, TCU

The 49ers got elite play out of Richard Sherman last year, but he is getting long in the tooth and can't be counted on for much longer. The experts agree that John Lynch and company will try to find his replacement, but it's uncertain which corner they'll land on. Gladney appears as likely as anyone.


32. Kansas City Chiefs: Kristian Fulton—CB, LSU

The first round comes to a close with a pick that the experts mostly agree on. Three out of six have the reining champs selecting sticky cover corner Kristian Fulton.

1,101 views2 comments


Thinking Orange
Thinking Orange
Apr 23, 2020

Sure! The experts were Kevin Hanson, Ryan McCrystal, Evan Silva, Matthew Jones, Brian Johannes, and Brendan Donahue. The Phins' secondary is awesome, and looks like it might get even better tonight...


Apr 18, 2020

Zay Simmons listed at DEFENDER

My boy Ezra Cleveland finally moving up draft boards, all the way to Cleveland!

I haven't seen Delpit in the first much, would you mind sharing your 6 experts? Great move to bring LOB back.

Love your commentary, "massive upside" of Becton, and the "undersized pass rusher"

Steelers trading 18th pick for Minkah is a rare case where trade worked out for both teams. Steelers saved face, and Phins get a younger swiss army knife in the secondary under contract to form best secondary in the league. AFC East will be the most interesting division for the first time in over 20 years

bottom of page